Brrrrrrrrupt! Brrrrrrrrupt!” A muddled fanfare penetrated Allison Reed’s sleep. She rolled over, hoping she was dreaming. She was pleasantly hot under the heaped up blankets and vaguely aware that she wanted to keep sleeping. But a few moments later the sound repeated – “Brrrrrrrrupt! Brrrrrrrrupt!” – followed by a bellowed “God bless the Mummers!” in the street below and Allison was awake and knew that it was New Year’s Day. Allison rolled onto her back and lay with her arms flat by her sides, unhappy with her mild hangover. Her head was heavy and her stomach was sour. Still, she felt a deep sense of physical satisfaction, which puzzled Allison for a moment until she remembered not only the two glasses of champagne she drank after midnight, but who she drank them with and how they laughed. She popped open her eyes to confirm what she now recalled quite clearly. She’d had sex with Jim D’Angelo and he was sleeping next to her. Allison closed her eyes and ran her hands down her body. She was naked and this made her uncomfortable. It was one thing to sleep with a man, if you could work up the necessary desire and nerve and you got to turn off the lights, and another thing, not as serious yet still intimate, to share your bed with him. But it was a different category of thing entirely to lay nude next to him all night. Naked was okay for sex, but once it was over, Allison wanted to get up, wash briefly, and dress. She expected the man to know he should do this, too, although experience had taught Allison not to take any chances. When she walked back into the bedroom wearing a nightshirt, modest yet sexy, she would announce, “I’ve brought you a fresh towel and a spare toothbrush,” in the easy tone of a thoughtful host. Only once had these been refused, back in her graduate school days when she was somehow convinced that you were missing experiences of great consequence if you weren’t rutting through a succession of over-serious, over-heated – in retrospect foolish and shallow and inept – affairs. “Nah, I’m okay,” the young academic had told her. Then Allison had cocked her head, briefly considered the enormity of her misjudgment, and invited the fellow to leave. This he did, with a look of confusion and regret that Allison accepted as an apology. She had not offered Jim D’Angelo a towel or a toothbrush, however, and Allison was reasonably certain she had not offered these because instead she had climbed on top of Jim and encouraged him to “go again” with a hip motion that made Allison wince with embarrassment. She opened her eyes again to see if Jim had caught her wincing. He was still asleep. This was the first time Allison had been with Jim D’Angelo and now he would think she was one of those women that men of his class seemed to particularly desire: accomplished in their profession, elegant in society, but all hell in bed. Once a man got dug into this opinion of a woman, Allison found, he held on to her like she was the Holy Grail – or worse, ecstatically concluded that she thought of sex the way he did, which was pretty much all the time and as the central organizing principle of life. This led to all sorts of tiresome nonsense. Sometimes it meant that the man wanted to have sex in places (the kitchen, parked cars, spare bedrooms at house parties) and in places (her body) where Allison was not interested in having it. Other times, it made him think that she was as fascinated by his penis as he was. The result of this belief was random trouser dropping and witty dingle waving, such as around corners or from opportune angles on the staircase. The first time Allison ran into this, she thought she had entangled herself with a freak. By the third or fourth iteration Allison realized that it was an endemic pathology of the human male, though this realization brought her little comfort. It did, however, provide a friend from college with the topic for her doctoral thesis. Allison sighed. What had she done? Where would it all lead? And what did she want from this man? It’s not that she regretted having Jim D’Angelo in her bed Eight months had passed since the last time Allison had slept with anyone and he’d delivered the goods quite competently. Jim D’Angelo was pleasant and successful, and Allison liked him. No one could say she’d made a mistake by having sex with him. But Allison had been in this position before, and before that too, and she wasn’t sure she wanted to be. Many of her friends had gotten married, some had started families, but Allison wasn’t afraid of falling behind them. She didn’t worry that they had taken husbands and she hadn’t. She didn’t feel a great aching hole in her life when she held their babies, although their children were lovely. What troubled Allison was the possibility that it didn’t matter. She was realistically, tolerably, intermittently happy. As happy, at least, as she thought it probable she could be, not possessing a genius for living, but not lacking a capacity for genuine enjoyment either. She had her job and her friends, a trinity house on a comfortable street, dinners and concerts and plays, three weeks in Italy one year, a month in Ireland the next, and all the privacy she desired. And she had men, more or less when she wanted them. This was a sufficient life. It satisfied her. She understood its limitations and endured its deficiencies, but she did so because she believed all lives had limitations and deficiencies. Would a husband and a family be more sufficient? Would they make her more happy? Or only as happy as she was now, just in a different way? But what about love? Allison admitted the possibility of love and did not deny its attraction, but when asked about it by her friends she always turned the question back on them. Do you love your husband? Of course, they’d answer and then Allison would ask, Why “of course” and not “yes”? A small pause. They knew Allison could be sharp, but she was rarely sharp with them. What’s the distinction? “Yes” is an affirmation, Allison would say, “of course” merely a habit. You’re playing word games with us. Perhaps I am, Allison would agree. And love can’t be all excitement forever, they’d tell her. See if excitement can survive a crying baby at 3 AM. And if it could, would you want it to? I love my husband, but I don’t want to love him like I did when I was twenty-five. That takes too much time, too much energy. I want to feel more settled. I want to grow up and move on. You had a husband once, you know, until you lost your nerve. I didn’t lose my nerve – I kept it, Allison always thought to herself when this subject was raised. Long ago, she’d learned that it was useless to argue or explain, so she didn’t try. She’d look away, let them think what they wanted about Matt, then talk about something else. Allison had loved Matt. The eight months they were together before their engagement was the happiest of Allison’s life and their engagement made Allison happy too. But sometime after they had selected the inn for the reception and agreed on the Caribbean for their honeymoon, Allison began to change her mind. At first, she didn’t understand she what was happening. She was simply puzzled by a tightness in her stomach whenever she discussed the wedding with Matt or their families. Then Allison found herself resenting Matt when he wanted to talk about how many people they should invite, how much they should spend on the food and music, or where they could find a decent minister. When the face in the mirror looked at her one morning and said, “You don’t want to marry that man,” Allison couldn’t have been more surprised than if a stranger had walked up and told her the same words. It didn’t make sense. Allison knew her feelings hadn’t changed because she tracked the strength of her attachment to Matt with an exactness she knew wasn’t healthy (I love him less today, by maybe ten percent, but I still love him. I love him much more today!) but which she persisted in all the same. So she tried to think. Allison shaded her eyes from the brightness of her love, looked at her and Matt as they were that day and found nothing, then looked toward the future. They didn’t want the same things, they didn’t like the same things. They never cared. They said it didn’t matter. They said it was a problem other people had. But at some point, Allison considered as she pushed at the knot in her stomach, their life would become about more than love. And when it did, she didn’t see how they could make that life work or how that life would make them happy. What to do? No one would blamed her if she married Matt – with qualms – and later realized it was a mistake and divorced him. She was young after all. The young were supposed to live by their hearts and not their heads. She might even get credit for believing in love against her better judgment. But that looked like cowardice to Allison. The waste of years, when she saw their marriage crumbling, depressed her. Most of all, Allison was afraid of losing her love for Matt. She might lose him – if that was the necessary outcome and unavoidable – but to lose the bright secret flame that Matt had kindled inside her, that seemed worse to Allison. She tried to avoid making the decision, of course. She hoped that a few weeks, and then a few more, would leave her feeling differently, but they didn’t, and the months before the wedding dwindled from six to four. Soon it would be too late to break the engagement with any decency. Plans would have been made, airline tickets purchased, hotel rooms reserved, new clothes bought, wedding presents ordered and sent. A decision that Matt could gloss over now with a shrug, a brave smile, and the words “she had second thoughts” to his family and friends would turn into an embarrassment and a humiliation with more delay. So Allison asked Matt to come to her apartment and she told him. At first, Matt thought it was a joke–he didn’t understand. And then he got mad. He walked out of her apartment, slamming the door, but he called early the next morning to apologize and they talked it through all again until Matt understood her. Then he asked if she was sure? Because he saw the problems Allison saw, but he was confident they would solve them. Wasn’t their love enough? Wasn’t their desire to keep loving, even when it wouldn’t be as easy as it was right now, enough? No, Allison said, shaking her head, it wasn’t. They talked like this, around and around and around, for an endless week: Matt trying to coax and convince her by turns, always optimistic, usually sympathetic, sometimes impatient while every conversation left Allison – against everything she honestly wanted – more deeply convinced of her unhappy certainty. She to make herself doubt, but she couldn’t and by the end, all the talking had thrown Allison into a state of such raw animal misery that when she begged Matt to let her go – begged mercy, begged pity – he agreed. He told their families, always used the word “we”, and insisted that their reasons were private. When Allison thanked him afterwards, he nodded once, said “okay,” and walked away. This wounded Allison, but she knew it was a wound of her own making; that the wound hurt most because in it she could feel how she had hurt Matt; and that in the final circumstance, Matt had added to his pain to ease hers. She’d asked far too much of him as it was. She couldn’t expect him to say goodbye with grace. And in truth, she was thankful he hadn’t. It helped Allison feel a little less guilty for what she had done. For several months, Allison cycled between shock and acute distress. She found the shock easier to handle because she could usually make it look like serenity to people who didn’t know her well. When the distress hit her, by contrast, Allison tended to grab her head and exclaim, “God, oh God, oh God!” regardless of where she was. This made going to work an adventure and Allison had to excuse herself from more than one meeting to seek out the reliably empty women’s room near the museum’s porcelain exhibit, lock herself in a stall, and groan through her hands for fifteen minutes. This same urge struck her on a Friday night at a restaurant where she had been taken by friends hoping to cheer her up for a few hours. Everything had been going fine. She was sitting at the bar, drinking the second cocktail they had ordered for her, and making an adequate display of emotional normality when she looked into the eyes of the bartender, exclaimed, “God, oh God, oh God!” and ran outside. After this, her friends urged her to get an anti-depressant, but Allison preferred to just stay home where she could slip into her bedroom and stick her head under her pillow until the mood passed. She did this frequently enough that the same friends, now transplanted with wine, dinner, and movies to her house, ceased to pay attention to it, particularly since she usually emerged looking refreshed. During all this time, Allison had one comfort that she kept secret. She had wanted to preserve her love for Matt, even at the cost of their marriage, and she had succeeded. Her love was still there, like a warm coal in her breast and at night, alone in her bed, she would take it out and breathe greedy and grateful life into it again. She never told anyone about this because she could guess at their expressions of horror and disbelief if she did. They would think she was selfish and thoughtless and cruel – and perhaps she was. Allison sometimes worried that she had wrecked Matt’s heart in the service of a monstrous vanity. She didn’t always recognize herself during those hours in the dark. She was strange and dangerous and she couldn’t put the name ‘Allison’ to the person she found. But there was still the fact of her pain and it was only the love that made it bearable. Neither lasted. Sometime between six and nine months after she broke up with Matt, Allison’s shock melted into equanimity and her distress lessened. The agony of what she had done could still attack her, sharp and sudden, but she was able to master her physical response to its assault enough to return to a public social life with little concern for embarrassment. But as she began to recover, the love grew cool then cold. She could remember it. She knew it had been real, but it was no longer alive. This was the last grief, and it would have been the hardest except that Allison had learned how to carry sorrow over the preceding months. She had become stronger, but also more remote and detached, and she wasn’t sure she liked the exchange. By thirteen or fourteen months, she began to date again, tentatively and infrequently, not because she wanted to begin seeing men again as much as because she wanted to avoid having conversations about why she wasn’t. And after a while, she began to enjoy herself, sometimes. She worried about what she would do if any of these relationships became serious, but that didn’t happen. Allison wasn’t sure she trusted the reason she found to explain why. Maybe it was that these men really weren’t interesting enough and funny enough and sexy enough to keep giving them her Saturday nights. That was true of some, certainly. But for others, perhaps it was her diffidence that ruined their chances. She knew it was there. She could feel it slamming down like a metal storefront grate, when a date was going well, and it puzzled her nearly as much as it puzzled the guy. “I’ve wrecked myself,” Allison would think after one of the nights that went wrong. “This is my fate.” Then she would sigh and shake her head. That was too dramatic, too absolute. She was much the same as she had always been: intelligent, self-regarding, reserved, modest, over-considerate, and intense. But Allison also knew that she didn’t want love as much as she did before she met Matt. On her worst days, Allison found herself thinking that love was a trivial luxury. “What’s the point of a new boyfriend?” she asked a close friend. “He’d be like a new pair of shoes. He might look good, and he might even feel right, but I have plenty in my closet already that I never bother to wear. And one in particular.” And yet, and yet. Here was Jim D’Angelo sleeping in her bed. So what does that mean, Allison asked herself. That I haven’t lost all hope? Or that I’ve gotten really good at kidding myself? She raised herself gently on one elbow to study Jim’s face. I’ve certainly fooled you, Allison thought. If you knew what you were getting from me, you’d probably run away. Run before I hurt you. What is it you thought you saw? Allison could have continued pushing her thoughts in this direction, but she didn’t. Instead, she gazed at Jim first with curiosity, then with an emotion that might have been affection. She had known Jim since October, and last night had been their eighth or ninth date, which was quite a lot considering all the holidays, so Allison decided she must fancy him at least. Two glasses of champagne wouldn’t have tricked her into sleeping with a man she didn’t. What was it about this one? Jim’s face was serene. He might have been sleeping in his own bed, Allison considered, for how easy he looked. On their first date, Allison had mistook Jim’s self-possession for blandness and decided she didn’t want to see him again but he’d convinced her otherwise with a steady application that was confident not assertive. It also took Allison several weeks to realize that Jim was funny. The problem was he had a dry sense of humor, and his occasional jokes were absurd interpretations and implausible inferences, which he slipped into their conversation so unobtrusively – the way a cheat might slip an ace into a deck of cards – that for a little while Allison had thought Jim suffered from an obscure mental-health disorder imperfectly controlled by medication. Jim could still fool her. Last night, he had made an observation that Allison had been at a complete loss to answer until a faint sparkle in his eyes told her there was no need. Allison laughed and Jim smiled, and she meant to nudge him with her elbow, but half-stumbled and bumped his body instead, and then her lips were pressed on his, Allison holding her glass out to one side and behind her so she wouldn’t spill it down the front of Jim’s suit, and suddenly the party couldn’t be over too soon. Allison raised her head and saw their clothes scattered on the floor. They had been in a hurry. She studied Jim’s face again. All this mysterious life whirling behind his steady expressions and dependable manners. Who was he? What did he want? He looked kind, but Allison knew how simple it would be to project the feelings she wanted onto Jim and she tried to resist the temptation. “Still, it’s not impossible,” she murmured. Except I don’t know you and you don’t know me. All at once, Allison felt how lonely she had been – for years, it seemed – and how much she didn’t want to be alone anymore. Oh god oh god, what am I doing? Did I kiss you out of despair? When I laughed, I fooled you. When you smiled back, you fooled me. We’ve double-fooled ourselves and each other. It was all an accident and a trick! I don’t want…. “I’m afraid,” Allison whispered. “I was always afraid, but I’m more afraid now.” Allison watched as Jim exhaled and his eyes blinked open. She had time to cover her breasts with the sheet, but she was caught raised on her elbow, looking down at Jim, and Allison was sure her face expressed her embarrassment. What would he say? How would he seem? Allison didn’t know what she’d do if Jim looked like he thought he had made a mistake or found some excuse to leave quickly. Her hair fell half over her face, but she didn’t have a free hand to brush it back. Jim rubbed his eyes briefly with the tips of his fingers and turned his gaze to Allison. If Jim was surprised to find her staring at him, he didn’t show it. He looked her steadily for a moment and reached up and tucked the loose hair behind her ear. Then he smiled. How Allison’s heart flew out to him! Jim’s smile was neither awkward nor overly familiar. Instead it was comfortable, reserved. She was conquered. All she had left was surrender. But Allison wouldn’t. Not today. I know love’s tricks, she thought. I know all its promises. I know how it works to fools us. I’m going to test it before I call it by name. I’m going to wait before I put our hearts at risk. She smiled at him, then she took a deep breath and said, “Hi.”
|
|
Peter McEllhenney lives with his wife and sons in the Queen Village neighborhood of Philadelphia.